Pilot Officer H L Cousins. Operation Sunrise – daylight raids on German battleships in Brest. Cold courage. Part 1.

During the Covid lockdown of 2020 Mr Leslie Cousins was surprised to discover his fathers personal diary amongst family papers. He was very generous and provided me with a copy.

This post is about Pilot Officer Herbert Leslie Cousins diary and the mission on which he paid the ultimate price. He was flying on a daylight called Operation Sunrise on 24 July 1941, as a member of 144 Squadron RAF based at RAF North Luffenham.

Pilot Officer H L Cousins

P/O Cousins and his wife Almer (married 28 October 1940) had one child, a son called Leslie, who was born in 1942 some nine months after his father’s death. P/O Cousins was killed by enemy fire during a raid on the Nazi capital ships docked in Brest, France on 24 July 1942. The Hampden aircraft he was the navigator/bomb aimer for returned to the UK but he had been fatally injured during the raid and was declared dead on landing. He is buried in St Illogan’s churchyard, near Redruth in Cornwall.

Mrs Almer Cousins

P/O Cousins joined the RAF on 3 June 1940 – leaving his role at Price Waterhouse and Co Chartered Accountants. He trained at RAF Cranwell, RAF Cranage, RAF Cottesmore (operational training unit) and was posted to a Hampden bomber squadron at RAF Hemswell in May 1941. The squadron moved to RAF North Luffenham on July 1941.

Pilot Officer H L Cousins

The diary covers the period 1 January 1941 to his death on 24 July 1942. It is written about his day to day experiences and observations about his domestic life. His diary reflects that life in 1941 was uncomfortable and sometimes unpleasant. His numerous rented accommodation (he had his wife Alma with him, whom he married in 28 October 1940) sounds hard.

In service life he had little income, travel across the country by train was tortuous and required many changes. He comments that his wireless and bicycle were sometimes rented and he had no car. He comments on some ‘dreadful’ Rutland land ladies!

In 1941 the winter weather was freezing and particularly in the air at altitude. He frequently mentions beer, and the lack of it. His most frequent off duty entertainments were ‘the flicks’and also bridge in the evenings. He did a lot of reading and spent much time wrestling with fiendish ‘Torquernada’ crosswords.

His diary reveals that weather was always commented on, other topics were frustration at bits of inadequate kit and orders, rumours (such as the invasion flap). He often comments that stuff was u/s – which is service slang for unserviceable.

One entry records that he has realised in July 1941 that 6 or 7 of his Cottemore course of 11 students were all dead. He also witnessed an Avro Manchester crash in flames near the airfield and he saw 2 airmen bale out, he desribed watching that as ‘horrible’ (this was probably a 61 Squadron Manchester, whose engines regularly failed resulting in fire).

In July 1941, the war was not going well. Britain stood alone and the Nazis occupied most of mainland Europe. Britain as always (as it is now) is dependent on imports of food and materials. After the fall of France, the Germans with battleships, U boats and the Focke Wulf Condor aircraft were once again trying to throttle Atlantic supply routes. The threat of invasion was also still present.

In May 41, the dramatic chase of the Bismark had taken place and she was hit by the HMS Prince of Wales and later by torpedoes launched by Fairy Swordfish aircraft. Whilst the Bismark was sunk the Nazis still had 3 of their largest fast offensive ships based in Western France which could challenge the Atlantic lifeline. This was a threat to national survival and at the time it was a critical target to be attacked.

The two battleships were the Scharnhorst and the Gneisenau. These ships were about 236m long and carried 11 inch guns and were capable of over 31 knots. The third ship was the heavy cruiser Prinz Eugen in Brest was armed with 8 inch guns, 207m long and was capable of over 30 knots.

The RAF was tasked with bombing the ships in port, mining approaches and also using torpedos. It was a major objective. The target was extremely well defended with fighters and flak. At the time the RAF jokingly referred to the three ships as the ‘Brest Bomb Target Flotilla’ and the RAF bombed and went back and bombed again and again to the French ports. Continually taking losses in machines and men. Eventually it led to the German Navy moving the ships in the Channel Dash on 11 February 1942.

Bombing and mining raids from North Luffenham and Woolfox would continue from early 1941 all the way through to the Channel Dash (e.g three 61 Sqn Manchesters were lost on the night of 31 Jan/1Feb 42 – 14 dead, 8 POW and 1 evader). A cursory count in Bomber Command Diaries shows that the target had been attacked 28 times before Op Sunrise.

On 24 July 1941 a major RAF operation called ‘Operation Sunrise’ was put into effect to bomb the ships Brest in daylight. However, the Sharnhorst had been moved to La Pallice which caused the raid plan to be modified. It was originally intended to task about 150 aircraft against Brest. This raid was now was split to the 2 ports. This would be no easy target. It was unlikely to be of any surpise to the defenders. The docks would be well defended with fighters, anti-aircraft guns and smoke to obscure the target. It would be considered a ‘cold courage’ target but because of its strategic significance, one where the RAF was prepared could expect to take heavy losses for the national effort.

During the Operation the RAF lost 21 aircraft for the 151 aircraft bombing (13.9 percent). Of the 660 men flying that day about 68 were killed, 38 went in captivity and 6 aircrew evaded capture (note these figures may be inaccurate). The Halifax and Wellington forces took serious casuaties. Hits were made on the warships – 4 on Gneisenau and 3 on Scharnhorst. The raid was judged a success, as the Sharnhorst was returned to Brest for repair, taking 4 months. The ships never sailed on raids and were moved to Bremerhaven in the Channel Dash (see post: http://www.rafnorthluffenhamheritage.me.uk/?tag=channel-dash

The individual losses are in the Bomber Command Losses book for 1941. Pilot Officer Cousins death was not recorded in Bomber Command Losses as the aircraft was not lost. His death is recorded in the unit operations record book (Form 540). Also a 144 Squadron Hampden was lost when it was shot down by fighters – Flt Lt Barr (3 killed and 2 POW).

F540 144 Squadron RAF July 1941

Plt Off Cousins is buried in St Illogan’s Church in Redruth Cornwall.

This post is incomplete, as the detail of what the crew did exiting the target area and how they fought fighters back across the channel and semi-crash landed at Predannack in Cornwall needs to be told in Part 2 of this post about P/O Cousins.

telegram

As I have stated before, as the stories about individuals crystalise I become more humbled and P/O Cousins sacrifice is one of cold courage, knowing that an attack in daylight would be costly and a true determined fight against fighters, flak and the environment. This is the definition of a battle. The dramatic illustration below is from a painting in the RAF Club in London (artist unknown).

King’s letter of condolence

Empty chairs and empty tables – Operation Fuller – 12 February 1942 ‘the Channel Dash’

A major event in the Battle of the Atlantic took place on the 12 February 1942. An account from the bomber command perspective is recorded that the Bomber Command War diaries for 1939 to 45.

the story is taken up as follows… The ‘Channel Dash’ took place where the German battle cruisers Scharnhorst and Gneisenau and the light cruiser Prinz Eugen set sail from Brest to move to Germany through the English Channel in a carefully prepared and well executed operation. Though the move had been anticipated the Germans gained surprise using bad weather. Despite best efforts of the Allies, the Germans suceeded and it was a national embarrasment that this had been achieved in ‘home waters’. The full story is recounted elsewhere. It was however, a significant tipping point as these ships did not sail again into the Atlantic and destroy shipping bringing supplies to the beleagured Great Britain.

Aircraft from North Luffenham were sent to the attack, although their departure was delayed until the afternoon as they had been on standby with armoured piercing bombs, which needed some height to use. Since the cloudbase was about 600 feet in the channel, the bomb load was switched to high explosive bombs, and this took time and I am sure a lot of groundcrew sweat powered by expletives.

My story links to this is when I served at RAF North Luffenham. When the station closed in 1998 I was present when a veteran called Jock Kennedy presented a painting to the last Station Commander, Group Capt Benstead. The painting had been hung in a corridor and showed Hampdens attacking battleships.

We gathered around for the presentation in the corridor leading into the dining room. The presentation was made and the veteran described why the presentation was in the corridor.

On 12 February 1942, 61 Squadron and 144 Squadron launched sorties (I do not know how many but this will be recorded in the operational record books) and that day 144 Squadron lost 2 aircraft. He said after having breakfast in the dining room with everyone, at the evening meal he had lost some friends and there were some empty seats at the table.

This stuck with me, having walked through that door many times. It is not easy to capture an event in time and space when the witnesses have gone or unless you were there. How can you capture these moments without witness testimony? Also also these events fade in time do people really care?

In the recent past I took the now ex chief executive of Rutland County Council to that spot and explained what had happened. Unfortunately, it seemed to me that she did not ‘get it’. It is highly likely that if MOD leave then the Officers Mess will be levelled and turned into houses.

The 2 aircraft lost were Hampdens AE141 and AT 175. With the loss of these two aircraft six men were killed including Wing Commander Simond (MID) the Officer Commanding 144 Squadron. Whilst AT 175 was lost without trace, with five crew members, AE141 was hit with flak managed to make an emergency landing at Norwich. Sgt Nightingale brought it home and died in hospital. Sgt Ivo Nightingale was from Kenya. He was awarded the distinguished flying medal (DFM) and is buried in Norwich cemetery. Further information on Sgt Nightingale is at Aircrew Remembered http://aircrewremembered.com/nightingale-ernest.html

Op Fuller Hamden losses
Entry from Bomber Command Losses 1942 – Op Fuller

I’m not sure how we can commemorate the sacrifice but perhaps by naming the main road within the Officers Mess complex Simond Road and Nightingale Road we might just forge a tenuous link to the past, the Channel Dash and commemorate their sacrifice.

On 12 February Bomber Command had dispatched 242 aircraft comprising 92 Wellingtons, 64 Hampdens, 37 Blenheims, 15 Manchesters, 13 Halifaxes, 11 Stirling’s and 10 Boston bombers. A large percentage of the aircraft crews never sighted the battleships due to the weather. 16 aircraft failed to return with the loss of 68 aircrew and five aircrew being captured becoming prisoners of war. You can read more about the Dash in wikepedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Channel_Dash

It may be that the mine laying by 61 and 144 Sqaudron prior to the breakout may have contributed to the damage sustained by the battleships entering German waters. Later missions were also launched to bomb them in harbour. At this time of the war, once again the nation’s food supply was being sunk by German U Boats. Due to the mine and bomb damage and on going bomb damage the battelships stayed in port.